There is a small wooden church in Bradenton that has survived yellow fever, the threat of demolition, and the relentless march of development. Today, it faces its next test — and a statewide coalition of preservationists has stepped in to help.
The 1887 Church at Manatee Village Historical Park was named to the Florida Trust for Historic Preservation's 2025 "Florida's 11 to Save" list — an annual designation that puts the state's most endangered historic sites in the spotlight and mobilizes expert resources and funding to help save them.
A Congregation That Persevered
Construction on the church began in 1887 but was briefly halted by a yellow fever outbreak sweeping through the community. The congregation persevered, completing the wooden structure in 1889. When it finally opened its doors, it became the first Christian congregation established on the Florida mainland south of Tampa — a distinction that makes it not just a local landmark, but a piece of Florida's foundational spiritual and community history.
For decades the church served its community. But by the mid-20th century, like so many historic structures, it faced an uncertain future. In 1975 — slated for demolition — it was saved by a group of determined local citizens, relocated to its current home, and made a cornerstone of the newly established Manatee Village Historical Park as part of Florida's Bicentennial preservation effort. The 1860 Manatee County Courthouse was moved alongside it.
A Living Museum Under Threat
Today, Manatee Village Historical Park is an open-air museum preserving the pioneer heritage of Manatee County's founding period (1840–1918). The park is managed in partnership with the Friends of Manatee Village, a nonprofit whose acting president, Andrea Knies, has been a driving force behind getting the 1887 Church the attention it needs.
"You can't replace history," Knies told Bay News 9. "And I also think historic buildings obviously cannot be replaced."
Knies, who has volunteered with historic societies since she was 15 years old, submitted the church's application to the Florida Trust's 11 to Save program herself — believing the designation would open doors to funding and expertise that the organization couldn't access alone. "We are going to have experts from all over the state," she said. "They're going to come together to help us with creative ways to make sure that we are able to preserve this building to its historical accuracy."
The need is real. The church requires a new roof and significant structural stabilization — the kind of work that demands both resources and specialized expertise in historic construction methods.
What "11 to Save" Means
The Florida Trust for Historic Preservation announces its 11 to Save list annually. Sites are nominated by the public and reflect places that local communities consider irreplaceable. The program is explicitly designed not just to raise awareness, but to trigger collaborative, custom solutions for each property — connecting local organizations with statewide preservation networks, funding sources, and technical expertise.
The 2025 list was announced at the Preservation on Main Street conference in Fernandina Beach. Alongside the 1887 Church, it includes the Magic Beach Motel in Vilano Beach, the St. Johns River Lighthouse in Duval County, the entire city of Cedar Key, and the Apalachicola Arsenal Officers Quarters.
"The 2025 Florida's 11 to Save reflect the extraordinary breadth and depth of stories that make up the cultural mosaic of our state," said Florida Trust Board President Mike Cosden. "By safeguarding these sites, we're not just preserving buildings and landscapes, but also the diverse histories and voices that contribute to our shared heritage."
The Suncoast has been well represented on the list in recent years. In 2024, the ancient indigenous burial mounds on Tidy Island in Bradenton and Warm Mineral Springs and Spa in North Port were both recognized. In 2023, Sarasota's Van Wezel Performing Arts Hall made the list.
Why It Matters to Neighborhoods Like Ours
The story of the 1887 Church is, in many ways, the story of every historic neighborhood: a community that built something meaningful, nearly lost it, saved it through collective will, and now must fight again to keep it.
For those of us in Point Pleasant, that arc is familiar. Historic structures don't preserve themselves. They survive because people decide they matter — and then do the work.
If you'd like to support the effort, the Friends of Manatee Village welcomes volunteers and donors. Learn more at manateevillage.org.
Sources: Pulse of Manatee (July 2025), Bay News 9 (August 2025), Florida Trust for Historic Preservation (floridatrust.org)